V5 Ultimate
Ultimate
PricingResourcesCompany
English (original)العربيةDeutschΕλληνικάEspañolFrançaisItalianoעברית日本語한국어NederlandsPolskiPortuguêsSvenska
Talk to us Log in Start free trial
Food & Beverage
  • Bakery & Confectionery
  • Food Processing
  • Ingredients & Dry Mixes
  • Sausage & Meat Products
  • Produce Packing
  • Pet Food & Pet Supplements
  • Dairy & Chilled Foods
  • Beverages & Liquid Manufacturing
  • Infant Formula
Pharma & Life Sciences
  • Radiopharmaceuticals
  • Pharmaceutical
  • Medical Devices
  • Veterinary Pharmaceuticals
  • Blood & Tissue
  • Diagnostics & IVD Kits
  • Reference Materials & Standards
  • OTC Topical Creams & Gels
Supplements & Personal Care
  • Dietary Supplements
  • Cosmetics & Personal Care
  • Cannabis & Hemp Manufacturing
  • Fragrances & Perfumery
  • Soaps & Personal Hygiene
  • Botanical Extracts & Essential Oils
Chemicals & Materials
  • Plastics & Resins
  • Agricultural Chemicals
  • Specialty & Industrial Chemicals
  • Printing Inks, Pigments & Construction Chemicals
  • Lubricants & Metalworking Fluids
  • Coatings, Adhesives & Sealants
Other Manufacturing
  • Consumer Products
  • Electronics & Electrical Assembly
  • Textiles & Nonwoven
  • Contract Manufacturing & Co-Packing
  • Packaging & Food-Contact Materials
  • Regulated Warehousing & Distribution
Explore all industries
  • Warehouse & TraceabilityReceive, store, pick and trace
  • Production & PlanningPlan jobs and guide production
  • Quality & LaboratoryTest, investigate and review
  • Documents & TrainingControl procedures and qualifications
  • Equipment & PerformanceMaintain assets and measure losses
  • Orders & IntegrationsConnect customers, suppliers and systems
  • Outputs & InsightsReports, KPIs and label design
Why V5? Product & Features
Why V5?Product & Features
  • Warehouse & TraceabilityReceive, store, pick and trace
  • Production & PlanningPlan jobs and guide production
  • Quality & LaboratoryTest, investigate and review
  • Documents & TrainingControl procedures and qualifications
  • Equipment & PerformanceMaintain assets and measure losses
  • Orders & IntegrationsConnect customers, suppliers and systems
  • Outputs & InsightsReports, KPIs and label design
Explore all industries
    • Bakery & Confectionery
    • Food Processing
    • Ingredients & Dry Mixes
    • Sausage & Meat Products
    • Produce Packing
    • Pet Food & Pet Supplements
    • Dairy & Chilled Foods
    • Beverages & Liquid Manufacturing
    • Infant Formula
    • Radiopharmaceuticals
    • Pharmaceutical
    • Medical Devices
    • Veterinary Pharmaceuticals
    • Blood & Tissue
    • Diagnostics & IVD Kits
    • Reference Materials & Standards
    • OTC Topical Creams & Gels
    • Dietary Supplements
    • Cosmetics & Personal Care
    • Cannabis & Hemp Manufacturing
    • Fragrances & Perfumery
    • Soaps & Personal Hygiene
    • Botanical Extracts & Essential Oils
    • Plastics & Resins
    • Agricultural Chemicals
    • Specialty & Industrial Chemicals
    • Printing Inks, Pigments & Construction Chemicals
    • Lubricants & Metalworking Fluids
    • Coatings, Adhesives & Sealants
    • Consumer Products
    • Electronics & Electrical Assembly
    • Textiles & Nonwoven
    • Contract Manufacturing & Co-Packing
    • Packaging & Food-Contact Materials
    • Regulated Warehousing & Distribution
PricingResourcesCompany
Start free trial Log in Talk to us
HomeGlossaryLoss on Drying vs Karl Fischer
Lab · The complete guide

Loss on Drying vs Karl Fischer: Choosing a Water Content Method

In short

Choose a water-content method by the material, the question being asked and the evidence needed to use the result.

4,245 words · ~20 min read
Loss on Drying vs Karl Fischer: a moisture analyser drying powder beside a Karl Fischer titration cell
Loss on drying measures total mass lost on heating; Karl Fischer titration measures water specifically.
On this page
  1. 01What each method measures—and what it cannot tell you
  2. 02When matching LOD and KF results are meaningful
  3. 03When results diverge: a 3.00% versus 1.20% case
  4. 04Which specification, monograph and product guidance govern the choice?
  5. 05Laboratory controls and records under 21 CFR Part 211
  6. 06Operational differences from sampling through method review
  7. 07Using moisture results in dispensing and basis corrections
  8. 08Linking analytical evidence to manufacturing systems
  9. 09Failure modes that undermine otherwise sound testing
  10. 10How V5 Ultimate supports the batch record
  11. 11Implementation and review checklist before routine use
On this page · 11 sections
  1. 1What each method measures—and what it cannot tell you
  2. 2When matching LOD and KF results are meaningful
  3. 3When results diverge: a 3.00% versus 1.20% case
  4. 4Which specification, monograph and product guidance govern the choice?
  5. 5Laboratory controls and records under 21 CFR Part 211
  6. 6Operational differences from sampling through method review
  7. 7Using moisture results in dispensing and basis corrections
  8. 8Linking analytical evidence to manufacturing systems
  9. 9Failure modes that undermine otherwise sound testing
  10. 10How V5 Ultimate supports the batch record
  11. 11Implementation and review checklist before routine use
AI · Explain it for MY operation

How does Loss on Drying vs Karl Fischer apply to your shop floor?

Pick your industry and scale — Ask V5 rewrites the definition in your context, gives a worked example, and shows what V5 does on day one.

Your scale

01What each method measures—and what it cannot tell you

Loss on Drying vs Karl Fischer is the comparison of nonspecific mass loss under defined drying conditions with water-specific measurement by Karl Fischer titration. The starting point is the quantity being measured, not which instrument appears more advanced or produces the lower result.

LOD reports the net mass change produced by its specified drying procedure, usually as a percentage of the initial sample mass. That loss can include water and other volatile material; heating can also cause decomposition. Temperature, duration, pressure and the endpoint therefore help define the result. LOD alone does not identify the substances responsible for the change.

KF determines water through its analytical reaction. Water specificity does not eliminate sampling error, incomplete extraction or chemical interference. A sample that gains water during handling, fails to release water into the reaction medium, or reacts with the reagents in another way can yield a misleading result despite the method’s water-selective principle.

TermWhat is measuredTypical expressionWhat the result does not establish
LODMass lost under specified conditionsPercent mass lossNot the identity of everything lost
KFWater determined by the procedurePercent water or mg/gNot interference-free recovery in every matrix
Water activityRelative water-vapour pressure at a stated temperatureDimensionless activityNot total water content
Residual-solvent testingSpecified solventsConcentrationNot total drying loss
Moisture balanceMass change under an instrument programPercent lossNot a separate water-specific chemistry

These distinctions prevent unlike measurements from being treated as synonyms. Water activity describes a vapour-pressure relationship rather than a mass fraction. Residual-solvent testing targets named solvents rather than everything removed by drying. A moisture balance remains a gravimetric measurement device even when its display labels the result “moisture.”

For method selection, first ask whether the intended attribute is drying loss, water content, water activity or a particular solvent. Those are different analytical questions; a shared percentage unit does not make their answers interchangeable.

02When matching LOD and KF results are meaningful

Agreement is scientifically plausible when both methods recover the same water from comparable samples. For this hypothetical case, assume representative portions of the same homogeneous material, water as the only component lost during drying, adequate removal of that water, no decomposition, and adequate water recovery by KF.

A net sample mass of 2.0000 g falls to 1.9800 g. The loss is 0.0200 g, so LOD = 0.0200 / 2.0000 × 100 = 1.00%. A matched KF result of 1.00% m/m equals 10.0 mg/g. Under these assumptions, the two results are consistent with the same water mass fraction.

One matching pair does not establish interchangeability. A proposed method-comparison study should cover representative lots, the intended concentration range and controlled sample handling, then assess bias, precision and decision limits. Correlation alone is insufficient: results can track each other while retaining a systematic difference that changes an acceptance decision. Consider measurement uncertainty when interpreting differences near a limit. Define comparison criteria before evaluating the study, based on the matrix and intended decision; there is no universal acceptable LOD–KF difference. Any conclusion should remain limited to the materials, range and conditions studied.

03When results diverge: a 3.00% versus 1.20% case

Assume matched, representative portions of one material, with both results reported on the same as-is mass basis. A 2.0000 g LOD portion falls to 1.9400 g after drying. Compare that measurement with a KF result of 1.20% m/m:

  • LOD loss = 2.0000 − 1.9400 = 0.0600 g; LOD = (0.0600 / 2.0000) × 100 = 3.00%.
  • KF water equivalent = 2.0000 × 0.0120 = 0.0240 g water per 2.0000 g of material.
  • Difference = 3.00 − 1.20 = 1.80 percentage points, equivalent to 0.0360 g on that reference mass.

The subtraction does not identify a chemical component: the gap is not a residual-solvent result. Higher LOD can reflect non-water volatiles or decomposition during heating. Lower KF can reflect incomplete extraction or loss of water during transfer. Either mechanism, or several together, could contribute; neither result automatically wins.

The reverse pattern also needs investigation. KF can exceed LOD when drying leaves water behind, but KF side reactions or atmospheric moisture entering the determination can increase apparent water. Hydration water may require different release conditions from surface moisture. Its release is not itself chemical decomposition; distinguish dehydration from chemical breakdown rather than assuming all water responds alike.

Investigate the cause, not the preferred number

  1. Sample comparability: examine sampling location, homogenization, storage and exposure history. Use controlled portions from the same representative sample to separate material variation from method effects.
  2. Reporting basis: confirm denominators, units and calculations before comparing percentages; do not compare an as-is result directly with a dry-basis value.
  3. Completeness: use targeted experiments to assess extraction time or drying conditions. A changed result is diagnostic evidence, not permission to replace the authorized procedure.
  4. Interference: examine blanks, atmospheric ingress and plausible matrix reactions. Where solvent loss or decomposition is suspected, use an appropriate independent measurement rather than assigning the entire gap to that cause.

Document the laboratory investigation. Only after assessing validity should reviewers select the result appropriate to the authorized specification—not whichever number is more favourable.

04Which specification, monograph and product guidance govern the choice?

Start with the material, intended use and destination market—not the instrument available in the laboratory. Read the applicable specification alongside any relevant monograph and product guidance. Keep binding requirements separate from ICH recommendations and from the practical document-review steps below.

Jurisdiction or product contextAuthority typeMethod-selection implicationScope check
Operations within U.S. Part 211 scopeBinding U.S. regulationCheck current laboratory-control requirements against the proposed method and governing specification; laboratory-record duties are covered next.Confirm applicability of 21 CFR Part 211 to the operation and product.
New drug substancesICH guidanceICH Q6A, water content paragraph e) accepts LOD as adequate in some cases but prefers water-specific detection, such as Karl Fischer.Use the drug-substance recommendation, not a dosage-form recommendation.
Solid oral drug productsICH guidanceICH Q6A, drug-product water content paragraph e) recommends a water-content test when appropriate, with criteria that may be justified by hydration or water-absorption data. LOD may be considered adequate in some cases; a water-specific procedure such as Karl Fischer titration is preferred.Assess appropriateness for the particular product.
Oral products requiring reconstitutionICH guidanceICH Q6A, paragraph m) considers LOD generally sufficient if development adequately characterizes absorbed moisture versus water-of-hydration effects. In certain cases a more specific procedure, such as Karl Fischer titration, may be preferable.Check that development evidence addresses that condition.
Non-aqueous parenterals and parenterals for reconstitutionICH guidanceICH Q6A 3.3.2.3(f) recommends proposing a water-content procedure and criterion when appropriate. It considers LOD generally sufficient for parenterals if absorbed moisture versus hydration effects were adequately characterized during development. In certain cases a more specific procedure, such as Karl Fischer titration, may be preferred.Keep the LOD condition attached to the recommendation.
EU/UK and other destination marketsMarket-specific requirements and guidanceCheck current applicable requirements, relevant monographs and the governing product specification before choosing or changing methods.Do not use the U.S. scope decision as a substitute for local review.
Food, supplements, devices and chemicalsCategory-specific requirements; material-specific practiceIdentify the applicable current requirements and specification for the material and intended use.Do not extend pharmaceutical provisions to these categories without an applicability assessment.

Read the specification before proposing substitution

As a practical specification-management sequence:

  1. Identify the exact material, grade, dosage form and applicable document version.
  2. Locate the named test and referenced procedure, including sample preparation and operating conditions.
  3. Confirm units, reporting basis and acceptance criterion; do not infer the basis from a percentage alone.
  4. Record which document governs the decision and resolve conflicting instructions before routine testing.

Treat replacing LOD with KF, or the reverse, as a technical change-control decision, not a synonym change. Review method suitability, interpretation of the existing limit and any product- or market-specific change obligations before authorizing substitution.

05Laboratory controls and records under 21 CFR Part 211

For operations within the scope of Part 211, 21 CFR 211.160(a) requires specifications, standards, sampling plans, test procedures and other laboratory control mechanisms, and any change to them, to be drafted by the appropriate organizational unit and reviewed and approved by the quality control unit. The same paragraph requires the subpart's requirements to be documented at the time of performance, and any deviation from the written specifications, standards, sampling plans or test procedures to be recorded and justified. Section 211.160(b) requires scientifically sound and appropriate specifications, standards, sampling plans and test procedures designed to assure conformity to appropriate standards of identity, strength, quality and purity. For a water method, that means the choice of LOD or KF, and any switch between them, is a controlled laboratory decision rather than an analyst preference. Where an established method is modified, 21 CFR 211.194(b) requires complete records of the modification, including the reason and data verifying that the modified method produces results at least as accurate and reliable for the material being tested as the established method.

Binding laboratory-record duties

21 CFR 211.194(a) requires laboratory records to include complete data from all tests necessary to establish conformity with established specifications and standards. For LOD or KF testing used for that purpose, the record obligation concerns the complete test data, not merely the reported percentage.

Under 21 CFR 211.194(a)(7), records must include the initials or signature of the person performing each test and the date or dates of testing. Under 21 CFR 211.194(a)(8), a second person’s initials or signature must show that the original records were reviewed for accuracy, completeness and compliance with established standards.

Practical evidence inventory

As laboratory traceability practice, organize the following evidence so a reviewer can reconstruct the measurement. These are recommended evidence categories, not a quotation of additional regulatory subsections or a prescribed validation protocol:

  • Sample identity and its connection to the material, lot and sampling event, supported by consistent production context tagging.
  • Method identity and revision, original observations and instrument output associated with the analytical execution.
  • Calculation inputs, units and reporting basis, allowing the reviewer to follow the path from observations to the reported result.
  • Exceptions encountered and review decisions, with clear authorship through attributable recording.

A final percentage alone cannot show which procedure produced it, which observations entered the calculation or whether an exception affected its interpretation. For method-suitability review, link the routine record to the scientific rationale and supporting studies relevant to the material and intended use. Keeping that rationale accessible helps reviewers assess whether the execution stayed within the conditions supporting the method’s use; collecting fields alone does not demonstrate suitability.

06Operational differences from sampling through method review

Neither method is universally faster, cheaper or more accurate. Compare the complete procedure for the material, including preparation, repeat measurements and review—not just instrument run time. These are operating considerations, not a regulatory checklist.

MethodControls to define and challenge
LODSample preparation and homogenisation; test-portion mass, vessel and loading depth; drying temperature, pressure and duration or stopping criterion; protected cooling; and the cooling/weighing sequence, including repeat cycles where specified.
KFSample introduction and actual mass delivered; dissolution or extraction conditions; reagent condition and, where applicable, titre; blanks or background drift; and endpoint evaluation, including stability and unexpected titration behaviour.

Volumetric KF delivers iodine through measured titrant; coulometric KF generates iodine electrochemically. Oven transfer is a sample-introduction configuration: heating releases water into a carrier gas for transfer to the titration cell. Select the configuration using expected water quantity, matrix compatibility and water-release behaviour. Oven transfer still needs assessment of transfer efficiency and potential thermal effects; it does not remove matrix-specific development work.

Design validation or suitability studies around the intended decision. Assess precision, response over the working range, recovery or extraction completeness, relevant interferences and robustness of critical conditions. A readily accessible water spike may titrate successfully while native bound water remains unreleased; spike recovery alone therefore cannot establish complete extraction. Challenge representative material states rather than relying only on added water.

Recommended seven-step lifecycle

Define intended use → Sample and protect → Prepare and identify → Confirm equipment readiness → Execute and evaluate → Review or investigate → Authorise intended use

Treat this workflow as recommended laboratory practice. Define containers, closures and exposure times during sampling, subdivision and weighing. Carry material, lot and test-portion identity through every stage; LIMS sample management can organise that traceability. Before execution, check relevant equipment calibration status and method-specific readiness. During review, retain the method, units and reporting basis alongside the result, evaluate anomalies and resolve investigations before authorising use. Reassess suitability when material behaviour or critical operating conditions change.

From test selection to reviewed use
  1. 1
    Define the decisionIdentify the material, jurisdiction and intended use.
  2. 2
    Select the methodMatch the specification and evaluate matrix risks.
  3. 3
    Control the sampleDefine collection, sealing, storage and exposure time.
  4. 4
    Perform the testCapture instrument output, settings, blanks and calculations.
  5. 5
    Check discrepanciesInvestigate conflicting results without overwriting original data.
  6. 6
    Review the recordHave an authorized person assess results and exceptions.
  7. 7
    Use the approved resultTransfer the identified result to its authorized use.
Each transfer preserves the sample, method version, reporting basis and review status.

07Using moisture results in dispensing and basis corrections

A moisture result belongs in a dispensing calculation only when the authorized formula calls for that adjustment. Define the target basis first: as-is includes the material as weighed; water-free excludes water; dried uses the loss under a specified drying procedure; solvent-free excludes the solvents named by the basis. These are not interchangeable labels. See as-is versus anhydrous reporting bases.

Worked case 3: an authorized water-only adjustment

Assume a target of 9.800 kg water-free material, representative KF water of 2.00% m/m on an as-is basis, and no other components excluded from the target basis. The manufacturing formula authorizes a water-only adjustment.

  • Water-free fraction = 1 − 0.0200 = 0.9800.
  • As-is quantity = 9.800 kg / 0.9800 = 10.000 kg.
  • Water in that quantity = 10.000 kg × 0.0200 = 0.200 kg.
  • Water-free material = 10.000 kg − 0.200 kg = 9.800 kg.

This hypothetical mass balance demonstrates the calculation, not permission to change a charge. In a moisture-corrected charge, an LOD correction and a KF correction can subtract different fractions from the denominator. Use the quantity specified by the approved basis, rather than substituting whichever percentage is available.

Keep potency correction separate. A water-free-material target is not automatically an active-ingredient target: non-water material can include other constituents. Before combining assay and water factors, determine whether the assay already incorporates the relevant basis adjustment. Applying it again can count the same effect twice.

For reproducibility, record the material and lot, sample/result identity, method, reporting basis, units, formula version, rounding rule and authorization. Retain the unrounded calculation alongside the rounded dispensing quantity, and carry the actual weighed mass into in-process reconciliation. These are recommended calculation controls, not independent authority to adjust the formula.

08Linking analytical evidence to manufacturing systems

Use five linked records to carry an LOD or KF result from the laboratory into a manufacturing decision. The field names below are a recommended system-neutral model, not regulatory terminology or a prescribed database design.

RecordIdentity and relationship
Samplesample_id identifies the sampled material and lot; each run references sample_id.
Method versionmethod_id plus method_version identifies the procedure used by the run.
Analytical runrun_id connects sample, procedure and execution evidence.
Reviewed Resultresult_id references run_id and retains value, unit, reporting basis and review status.
Downstream useThe manufacturing decision references result_id and records its specific use, such as a dispensing calculation.

Define an integration contract across the laboratory information management system, instrument export and manufacturing application. Preserve identifiers, method version, value, unit, reporting basis and review status at every handoff. Keep LOD and KF method identities distinct even when their numerical results match. A successful transfer acknowledges delivery; it does not establish scientific approval. In MES–LIMS integration, eligibility for downstream use should depend on the recorded human review decision, not merely receipt of a file.

Plan exception recovery before routine transfer:

  • Duplicate messages: match stable message and result identifiers before retrying; avoid creating another result or repeating its downstream use.
  • Wrong-lot mappings: quarantine the import until sample and lot identities are reconciled.
  • Missing units or stale method revisions: block use pending documented resolution; never silently reinterpret a unit or substitute the most recent result.
  • Interrupted transfers: reconcile acknowledgements and stored identifiers before resending; do not expose partially received records as usable results.

Preserve the original payload and record who resolved each exception, when, why and what changed. Link that audit trail to the affected result and batch execution history.

Moisture Result and Decision Traceability

Sample

Lot identity and handling history.

  • sample_id
  • material_lot_id
  • sampled_at
  • container_id
  • exposure_time_min

Method Version

Procedure, reporting basis and specification.

  • method_id
  • method_version
  • method_type
  • reporting_basis
  • specification_id

Analytical Run

Execution linked to original data.

  • run_id
  • sample_id
  • method_id
  • method_version
  • instrument_id
  • raw_data_uri

Reviewed Result

Value with accountable review status.

  • result_id
  • run_id
  • result_value
  • result_unit
  • review_status
  • reviewed_by
  • reviewed_at

Result Use

Decision linked to the reviewed result.

  • use_id
  • result_id
  • work_order_id
  • correction_factor
  • authorized_by
A system-neutral model connects each manufacturing use to its sample, method and analytical evidence.

09Failure modes that undermine otherwise sound testing

Sound analytical execution does not guarantee a sound disposition decision. The following are quality-risk controls based on industry practice, not a universal investigation procedure. They address how evidence is selected, interpreted and acted on.

Failure modeWhy the decision becomes unreliableControl
Selecting a passing repeat while disregarding the initial resultSelective evidence useRetain and assess the complete sequence.
Acceptance limits finer than demonstrated method capabilityUnstable pass/fail decisionsReview capability against the decision boundary.
Uncontrolled spreadsheet formulaUnreviewed basis or arithmetic changesUse versioned and challenged calculations.
Unresolved discrepancy without an ownerIndefinite or inconsistent dispositionAssign named responsibility and documented decision criteria.

Averaging LOD and KF to obtain a compromise value is generally inappropriate. The average can combine different measured quantities rather than resolve the cause of disagreement. A midpoint is not evidence that either result is valid, nor does it establish which result answers the specification’s question.

Tie repeat testing to a defined investigation question: for example, whether a suspected preparation error explains the original observation. Specify what evidence would support or reject that explanation before repeating the test. In an out-of-specification investigation, a passing repeat is additional evidence—not, by itself, a reason to discard the initial result.

Where the investigation identifies a recurring governance weakness, connect corrective action to the quality assurance process. Assign an owner and an effectiveness check that tests the failed control, rather than merely confirming that subsequent batches passed.

10How V5 Ultimate supports the batch record

Record assembly, not analytical authority

V5 Ultimate’s batch record brings together lab samples, QC check results, electronic signatures and deviations. This is record assembly supporting review—not automated selection of LOD or Karl Fischer. For this workflow, treat the assembled record as supporting evidence, not as a decision about which analytical method is suitable or whether its result justifies release. Authorized humans approve method decisions and batch release; assembling the record does not confer that authority on the software.

11Implementation and review checklist before routine use

Use these suggested practice gates before authorizing routine LOD or Karl Fischer testing or a new manufacturing use. Record the evidence, decision and accountable owner for each gate; unresolved items should remain visible rather than becoming implied approvals.

Analytical readiness

  • Is the intended decision defined—specification assessment, process monitoring or a basis correction—and is the applicable specification identified? Use the specification-selection discussion above.
  • Are the method version and matrix suitability established for the intended range? Identify the validation or verification evidence and an owner for the analytical rationale; connect unresolved development questions to the site's analytical procedure development approach.
  • Is the reporting basis unambiguous? Assign routine execution to trained analysts and confirm that training records cover the actual procedure, not merely the instrument.

Record readiness

  • Can another reviewer reconstruct the result from original observations, calculations and method settings? Assign result review to a named role and test this with a representative completed record.
  • Can an LOD–KF discrepancy be traced to its investigation, scientific assessment and final decision? Use the divergence discussion above rather than accepting an unexplained preferred value.
  • Can a transferred value be followed back to its analytical run? Assign ownership for interface exceptions and demonstrate recovery using the controls discussed under MES-to-LIMS integration.

Manufacturing-use readiness

  • Is the intended user authorized to apply the result to this manufacturing decision, rather than merely able to view it?
  • Can a dispensing adjustment be recalculated from identified inputs, units and the approved formula? Assign ownership for manufacturing calculations and use the basis-correction discussion above.

Define reassessment triggers: a material or supplier change, altered method conditions, changed reporting or calculation logic, or an unexpected result pattern. Assign responsibility for evaluating each trigger and deciding whether additional evidence is needed before continued use; avoid an arbitrary universal review interval.

Frequently asked questions

Q.Can a supplier's LOD certificate support acceptance when my specification calls for Karl Fischer?+

Treat the supplier’s LOD result as supporting information, not as a substitute for the specified KF result. LOD measures mass lost under defined drying conditions; that loss can include substances other than water. Request a result using the specified method, or evaluate an alternative through an approved, scientifically justified process before relying on it. Keep the material’s acceptance decision separate from supplier qualification. The distinction between LOD and KF moisture testing matters even when both certificates report percent.

Q.How should a reviewer handle a limit of “not more than 0.50%” when the method or reporting basis is unclear?+

Pause the acceptance decision and resolve what the percentage represents: water by KF or mass loss by LOD, and the denominator used. Confirm the method revision, sample preparation, units, calculation and rounding convention. Assuming mass percent on an as-received basis, 0.50% means 0.50 g per 100 g of original sample; a dry-basis value uses a different denominator. Resolve reporting-basis differences before assigning an in-spec or out-of-spec status. Do not choose whichever interpretation produces acceptance.

Q.What should analysts investigate when oven KF and direct KF give different results on the same material?+

Start with matched, representative portions and controlled exposure during sampling. For direct KF, investigate dissolution or extraction completeness, reaction time and matrix interference. For oven KF, investigate temperature, transfer time, carrier-gas conditions, leaks, blanks and possible thermal decomposition. Either approach can read low through incomplete water recovery or high through interference or introduced moisture. Compare results across justified preparation conditions; spike recovery can help assess performance, but recovery of added water alone does not establish complete release of native bound water.

Q.Can a laboratory use a correction factor to predict KF water content from LOD results?+

A correction factor can support a defined prediction model, but multiplying LOD by a constant does not turn it into a water-specific measurement. Establish paired LOD and KF data across representative lots, moisture levels and relevant process variations. Assess bias, prediction error and performance near the acceptance limit, then test the model on independent samples. Restrict its use to the demonstrated material and conditions. Keep predictive testing separate from water/LOD formulation compensation, which addresses a different calculation purpose.

Q.Can two foods with the same KF water result have different storage or spoilage risks?+

Yes. KF measures water content, whereas water activity describes water’s thermodynamic availability. Foods with equal water percentages can have different water activities because their salts, sugars, proteins and physical structures differ. Their storage risks can also differ with pH, preservatives, packaging, temperature and initial contamination. Use product-specific water-activity measurements and shelf-life evidence rather than inferring microbial stability from KF alone. A low water result is not proof that a food lacks pathogens or will remain stable throughout storage.

Q.When should changing a drying temperature, extraction solvent or KF reagent trigger method reassessment?+

Trigger a documented assessment whenever the change could affect what is measured or how completely it is recovered. Higher drying temperatures may remove additional volatiles or cause decomposition; a different extraction solvent may change water recovery; another KF reagent may alter matrix compatibility or reaction behavior. Use change control to define comparative testing and acceptance criteria before routine adoption. The assessment should determine whether targeted checks or broader validation are appropriate, with compatibility studies informing matrix-specific concerns.

Q.How can a manufacturer decide whether an earlier moisture result still represents material at dispensing?+

Evaluate the interval since sampling against the material’s moisture sensitivity and actual storage history. Review container closure, liner integrity, opening frequency, humidity exposure, temperature and any drying or conditioning steps. A sample from an unopened container may not represent material after repeated partial withdrawals. Establish a justified hold time or event-based retest rule using representative data. Connect sample identity and handoff to the container being dispensed, and use a moisture checkpoint when current moisture affects the dispensing decision.

Q.What should a reviewer do when a repeat moisture test passes after the initial result failed?+

Do not let the passing repeat erase the initial result. Review both datasets, sample identity, calculations, instrument performance, preparation details and exposure between tests. Moisture can change during handling, so a later sample may represent a different condition rather than demonstrate an analytical error. Follow the established out-of-specification investigation process, with a justified retest plan rather than testing until acceptance. Document any assignable cause and its supporting evidence; an authorized human reviewer should assess the investigation before disposition.

Primary sources

  • ICH Q6A Guideline
  • 21 CFR 211.194 Laboratory records
Talk to us about Loss on Drying vs Karl Fischer

Want to see how Loss on Drying vs Karl Fischer could fit into your own records and workflows? Explore the related V5 pages or talk to our team about what applies to your operation.

Start free
Back to glossary
Related terms
  • → Water / LOD Compensation
  • → Moisture Correction Charge
  • → As-Is vs Anhydrous Basis
  • → Capsule LOD & Shell Moisture

Next Step

Try V5 with your own records, or ask a question first. Ask V5 opens with an editable question; nothing is sent until you choose to.

Start your free trial Browse All Features

Showing the site for the United States. Local spelling, dates and prices are applied automatically; change the language at the top of the page.

V5 Ultimate
Ultimate

Warehouse, quality and manufacturing software for regulated operations.

ProductIndustriesPricingResourcesSecurity & TrustCompanyLegal Centre

© S.G. Systems, LLC