FTC Made-in-USA Rule & Endorsement GuidesFTC Made in USA Labeling Rule, Endorsement Guides and Consumer-Protection Enforcement
A deep dive into the FTC’s 2021 Made in USA Labeling Rule and the updated Endorsement Guides for transparent marketing.

On this page · 9 sections
- 1The Power and Protection of the 'Made in USA' Claim
- 2The Legal Framework: 16 CFR Part 323
- 3The 'All or Virtually All' Standard
- 4Qualified Claims: Navigating the Gray Areas
- 5Documenting Origin: Substantiation and the BOM
- 6The Role of 16 CFR Part 255: Endorsements and Testimonials
- 7Enforcement, Penalties, and the 2021 Update
- 8Cross-Agency Coordination: FTC, CBP, USDA, and FDA
- 9Compliance Best Practices in Regulated Manufacturing
How does FTC Made-in-USA Rule & Endorsement Guides apply to your shop floor?
Pick your industry and scale — Ask V5 rewrites the definition in your context, gives a worked example, and shows what V5 does on day one.
01The Power and Protection of the 'Made in USA' Claim
In the global marketplace, a 'Made in USA' label carries significant weight. For many consumers, it is a symbol of quality, safety, and support for the domestic economy. Because of this influence, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) maintains strict oversight to ensure that U.S. origin claims are truthful and substantiated. The core of this oversight is the 'all or virtually all' standard, a high bar that requires products bearing an unqualified U.S. origin claim to be almost entirely manufactured within the United States using domestic components.
The landscape of U.S. origin claims changed significantly in 2021 with the finalization of 16 CFR Part 323, the Made in USA Labeling Rule. Before this, the FTC primarily relied on the FTC Act and a 1997 Enforcement Policy Statement to address deceptive claims. The new rule codifies the 'all or virtually all' standard and gives the Commission the authority to seek significant civil penalties for violations. For manufacturers in regulated industries—such as pharmaceuticals, dietary supplements, and medical devices—understanding these rules is critical for avoiding both regulatory action and brand damage.
02The Legal Framework: 16 CFR Part 323
The Made in USA Labeling Rule, 16 CFR Part 323, is the primary regulation governing unqualified U.S. origin claims on product labels. Effective August 13, 2021, the rule defines 'Made in the United States' as any unqualified representation, express or implied, that a product or service is of U.S. origin. This includes terms like 'manufactured,' 'built,' 'produced,' or 'crafted' in the United States 1.
The rule applies to 'labels,' which the FTC interprets broadly. A label includes any mark, tag, stamp, or seal that appears on the product or its packaging. Crucially, the rule also extends to 'mail order catalogs' and 'mail order promotional materials,' which include websites and electronic advertisements that solicit purchases without the consumer examining the actual product 2.
Prohibited Acts Under the Rule
Under 16 CFR § 323.2, it is considered an unfair or deceptive act to label a product as 'Made in the United States' unless three specific conditions are met:
- The final assembly or processing of the product occurs in the United States.
- All significant processing that goes into the product occurs in the United States.
- All or virtually all ingredients or components of the product are made and sourced in the United States.
This three-pronged test creates a rigorous standard that excludes products with significant foreign content or those that undergo only minor assembly steps on U.S. soil 3.
03The 'All or Virtually All' Standard
The 'all or virtually all' standard is the most challenging aspect of the FTC’s requirements. An unqualified claim means the product must contain no more than a negligible amount of foreign content. While the FTC does not provide a fixed percentage for what constitutes 'virtually all,' it evaluates claims based on several factors, including the cost of foreign components relative to the total manufacturing cost and the significance of those components to the product's function.
For example, a supplement manufacturer using vitamins synthesized in China and encapsulating them in the U.S. cannot claim the product is 'Made in USA.' Even if the encapsulation occurs domestically, the primary ingredients (the vitamins) are foreign-sourced, violating the 'all or virtually all' requirement.
Factors in the FTC Analysis
- Site of Final Assembly: The product must be transformed in the U.S. into a finished good.
- Portion of Manufacturing Cost: The FTC looks at the percentage of total manufacturing costs that are attributable to U.S. parts and labor.
- How Far Back the Foreign Content Goes: If a component is made in the U.S. but is itself made from foreign raw materials, those materials must be accounted for in the 'virtually all' assessment.
04Qualified Claims: Navigating the Gray Areas
If a product does not meet the 'all or virtually all' standard, the manufacturer can still make a U.S. origin claim, provided it is 'qualified.' A qualified claim includes caveats or explanations that prevent consumer deception. These claims must be clear and prominent, and they must accurately reflect the extent of the product's U.S. content or processing.
Common examples of qualified claims include:
- 'Made in USA with imported parts.'
- 'Assembled in USA with U.S. and foreign components.'
- '60% U.S. content.'
- 'Packaged in USA.'
Avoiding Deceptive Implied Claims
Manufacturers must be careful with implied claims. Using a U.S. flag icon, an outline of the United States, or phrases like 'American Quality' on a product that is mostly foreign-made can be considered a deceptive unqualified claim, even if the word 'Made' is not used. The FTC looks at the 'net impression' the label makes on a reasonable consumer.
In the context of pharmaceuticals, if a drug is formulated in the U.S. but uses an Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient (API) from overseas, a label stating 'Manufactured in the USA' without qualification would likely be deceptive. The API is too 'significant' to be ignored under the 'all or virtually all' standard.
05Documenting Origin: Substantiation and the BOM
The FTC requires that all U.S. origin claims be substantiated by 'competent and reliable evidence' before the claim is made. This means a manufacturer cannot wait for an audit to start gathering data; the proof must exist at the time of labeling.
The primary tool for substantiation is the Bill of Materials (BOM). Manufacturers must analyze their entire supply chain, looking at each component's origin and the cost of every input. This requires close collaboration with suppliers to obtain accurate Certificates of Origin (CoO) or formal declarations.
| Substantiation Element | Description | Required Documentation |
|---|---|---|
| Final Assembly Location | Proof that the last substantial transformation happened in the U.S. | Production records, time stamps, facility logs. |
| Component Origin | Evidence of where every significant part or ingredient was made. | Certificates of Origin, Supplier Declarations. |
| Cost Analysis | Calculation of domestic vs. foreign cost (COGS). | Detailed BOM with cost breakdown per component. |
| Processing Depth | Documentation of the 'significance' of U.S. labor/overhead. | Work instructions, labor hours, manufacturing overhead allocations. |
06The Role of 16 CFR Part 255: Endorsements and Testimonials
While the Made in USA Rule focuses on origin, the FTC’s 'Guides Concerning Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising' (16 CFR Part 255) govern how reviews and testimonials are used in marketing. For companies touting their American-made status, customer reviews can be a powerful tool, but they must be handled with transparency 2.
The 2023 update to the Endorsement Guides emphasized several key principles:
- Authenticity: Testimonials must reflect the honest opinions, beliefs, and experiences of the endorser.
- Disclosure of Material Connections: If an endorser (e.g., an influencer or a customer given a free product) has a connection to the brand that might affect the weight or credibility of their statement, that connection must be clearly and conspicuously disclosed.
- Prohibition of Fake Reviews: Brands cannot commission fake reviews or suppress negative ones to create a misleading impression of customer satisfaction.
Incentivized Reviews and U.S. Origin Claims
If a manufacturer incentivizes a customer to leave a review specifically mentioning the 'Made in USA' quality, the brand must ensure the disclosure is prominent. Simply burying a 'sponsored' tag at the bottom of a page is insufficient. The FTC’s goal is to ensure consumers understand when a recommendation is not entirely independent.
07Enforcement, Penalties, and the 2021 Update
The finalization of the Made in USA Labeling Rule in 2021 was a major shift for the FTC. Previously, the Commission could only seek cease-and-desist orders for first-time offenders. Under 16 CFR Part 323, the FTC can now seek civil penalties for every violation of the rule 5.
As of 2024, the maximum civil penalty for a violation is $51,744 (adjusted annually for inflation). Because the FTC can consider each label or each website visit as a separate violation, the potential financial exposure for a broad deceptive marketing campaign can reach millions of dollars.
"The final rule provides substantial benefits to the public by protecting businesses from losing sales to dishonest competitors and protecting purchasers seeking to purchase American-made goods."
The FTC also actively monitors digital platforms. In recent years, the Commission has brought numerous actions against companies selling through online marketplaces that used 'Made in USA' logos while importing finished goods from overseas. These cases often result in significant settlements and mandatory monitoring programs.
08Cross-Agency Coordination: FTC, CBP, USDA, and FDA
One of the most common points of confusion for manufacturers is how the FTC rule interacts with other federal agencies. Compliance with one agency's rules does not necessarily equate to compliance with another.
FTC vs. CBP
U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) requires that all goods of foreign origin imported into the U.S. be marked with their country of origin (e.g., 'Product of France'). The FTC, however, governs U.S. origin claims. A product might be exempt from a CBP foreign-origin marking (because it was 'substantially transformed' in the U.S.) but still fail the FTC's 'all or virtually all' test. In such cases, the product may be left without a U.S. origin claim, even if it is not legally required to be marked as foreign.
USDA Country of Origin Labeling (COOL)
The USDA’s Agricultural Marketing Service enforces COOL for specific food products, including beef, pork, lamb, chicken, and produce. These rules are distinct from the FTC's Made in USA rule. COOL is a mandatory disclosure for these categories, whereas Made in USA claims are generally voluntary marketing decisions (unless required by specific procurement laws).
FDA and Cosmetics/Drugs
The FDA governs the labeling of drugs, biologics, and cosmetics. While the FDA focuses on safety and efficacy, the FTC retains jurisdiction over the U.S. origin claims made on these products. Manufacturers must ensure that their FDA-mandated labels (listing the place of business of the manufacturer/packer/distributor) do not inadvertently create a deceptive U.S. origin claim.
09Compliance Best Practices in Regulated Manufacturing
Maintaining a defensible 'Made in USA' claim requires a systematic approach to supply chain transparency. Relying on verbal assurances from suppliers is insufficient; manufacturers must build a robust verification process into their Quality Management System (QMS).
- Perform a Comprehensive BOM Audit: Review every line item in the Bill of Materials. Calculate the cost of all foreign parts, including raw materials, and compare them to the total manufacturing cost.
- Require Written Declarations: Request formal U.S. origin declarations from all domestic suppliers. Ensure these declarations specify if the components themselves contain foreign content.
- Monitor Supply Chain Shifts: A product that met the 'virtually all' standard last year may no longer qualify if a key supplier switched to a foreign raw material source. Regular re-evaluation is necessary.
- Use Clear Qualifications: If there is any doubt about meeting the 'all or virtually all' standard, pivot to a qualified claim. It is far safer to claim 'Assembled in USA with domestic and imported components' than to risk an unqualified 'Made in USA' claim.
Ultimately, the Made in USA label is a promise to the consumer. By adhering to the FTC's rigorous standards and maintaining detailed substantiation, manufacturers can leverage the power of American manufacturing while mitigating the risks of regulatory enforcement.
Frequently asked questions
Q.What does 'all or virtually all' actually mean?+
It means the product must contain no more than a negligible amount of foreign content. The FTC considers the site of final assembly, the percentage of total manufacturing costs attributable to foreign components, and the significance of those foreign parts to the product's function.
Q.Can I use the U.S. flag on my label without saying 'Made in USA'?+
Possibly, but it is risky. The FTC evaluates the 'net impression' of a label. If the use of a flag icon implies to a reasonable consumer that the product is made in the U.S., it is treated as an unqualified claim and must meet the 'all or virtually all' standard.
Q.Does the 2021 Rule apply to online stores?+
Yes. The Made in USA Labeling Rule (16 CFR Part 323) specifically covers 'mail order promotional materials,' which includes website product pages, digital advertisements, and social media posts that solicit a purchase.
Q.What is the penalty for a Made in USA violation?+
The FTC can seek civil penalties of up to $51,744 per violation (as of 2024, adjusted for inflation). A 'violation' can be defined as each deceptive label produced or each time a consumer views a deceptive digital advertisement.
Primary sources
Further reading
- Claims SubstantiationUnderstand the general requirements for proving advertising claims before they reach the consumer.
- SmartLabelHow digital disclosure platforms are managing the squeeze on physical label real estate.
- Certificate of Analysis (CoA)The critical document for verifying raw material specifications and origin data.
- Bill of Materials (BOM)The foundation of origin analysis and cost calculation in manufacturing.
Want to see how FTC Made-in-USA Rule & Endorsement Guides could fit into your own records and workflows? Explore the related V5 pages or talk to our team about what applies to your operation.
